Skip to content
Verified account. Company monitors its reviews.

Agape Diamonds is a paying client of PissedConsumer and utilizes its services to proactively identify and correct customer service issues.

Agape Diamonds

Agape Diamonds

Claimed company
56
Company responses
17
Customer testimonials
Call customer care
Show reviews that mention
diamonds order fake consumer protection impression upgrade sale dollars zirconias
Filter review

What Their Customers Are Saying

?

All testimonials are provided and verified by Agape Diamonds. Verified testimonials on PissedConsumer is a paid feature of the platform.

Agape Diamonds
1 of 1
I purchased a three diamond ring and asked my GF to marry me almost 2 years ago. 1 year anniversary on May 18th, 2020. We decided to buy two bands for another style ring and asked to have all 3 rings joined together. Absolutely amazing end result. We have both gotten countless remarks on the unique design, brilliance and there is no doubt "someone really loves you" as many say. The price, service and quality literally stands out against others.... Read more

Absolutely would recommend to everyone!

Agape Diamonds
One of the best companies I have ever ordered online from. The website was easy to navigate and when I called about some questions I had the customer service was excellent - very helpful, knowledgable and polite. It became stress free and when the product arrived I could not be more thrilled! It was PERFECT and my fiancé LOVED it! Thank you Agape Diamonds for helping make our engagement so special!

Great product and service

Agape Diamonds
Purchased a diamond ring from Agape Diamonds this past December and I wanted to post a review about my experience. The product was shipped on time and arrived in a beautiful packaging the engagement ring and matching band excellent quality and the package even arrived with a free pair of earrings that I was able to give to my granddaughter the customer service at Agape Diamonds was great the customer service rep that I spoke to took her time with me on the phone and walked me through the whole process. A+ company and would Recommend them to my family and friends

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jun 08, 2026 to: Jacqueline H Uxb's review

Please contact our Customer Service team at customerservice@agapediamonds.com for assistance.
As all jewelry is made to order, please allow up to 7 business days for production before your order ships.
Thank you for your business and for choosing Agape Diamonds. We appreciate your support and look forward to serving you.
Kind regards,
Agape Diamonds Customer Service Team
Jacqueline H Uxb

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

I have a order I have not received I...

I have a order I have not received I get emails asking what I think of items gold bracelets 4 of them gifts for my granddaughters I have called numerous times only to be on hold over an hour each time I have yet to speak with a person after this is resolved we won't do anymore busi ess with this company I have spent alot of money with you I'm sure don't concern you but I would appreciate this being resolved my order # *** ***

Preferred solution:

Deliver product or service ordered

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jun 05, 2026 to: JLe N's review

Thank you for reaching out, Please email customerservice@agapediamonds.com for assistance
JLe N

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Stockton, California

Deceptive marketing, diamond is worth two Big Macs

I purchased a ring from Agape Diamonds a few years ago, believing I was buying a lab-grown diamond based on how their website and branding were presented at the time.

In March 2026, I reached out to the company directly to raise concerns that their previous website domain, diamondslabcreated.com, could reasonably lead consumers to believe they were purchasing lab-grown diamonds. The use of lab created in the domain name, combined with product descriptions using the word diamond, made it unclear that the stones may actually be simulants rather than true lab-grown diamonds.

Shortly after I raised this concern, I noticed that the company changed their domain to agapediamonds.com, removing the lab created language altogether.

To me, this reinforces the concern that the original branding and domain name could be misleading to consumers.

Additionally, the value of the product has been extremely disappointing.

I paid around $3,000 for this ring, and after attempting to resell it, I found it has little to no resale valuereceiving offers under $100. That is a significant difference and not something I would have expected when making a purchase at that price point.

Had the nature of the stone and its actual market value been clearly explained upfront, I would not have made this purchase.

When I contacted customer service, I did not feel my concerns were taken seriously, and the response felt dismissive.

Im sharing my experience so others can carefully review the details of what is being sold and make a fully informed decision.

Loss:
$3000
Preferred solution:

Full refund

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jul 11, 2025 to: Michelle T Arg's review

Thank you for reaching out top Agape Diamonds, we offer free returns within 30 days of purchase! Please reach out to our customer service department at customerservoce@agapediamonds.com to set up a return. Also please know that we offer all 3 types of diamonds. Lab grown Diamonds, Simulated Diamonds and natural diamonds if you wish to exchange your order. We thank you for your business and for choosing Agape Diamonds!
Michelle T Arg

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Tampa, Florida

I was under the impression that I was getting real diamonds only to find out that after it shipped that I was getting a fake! I had to look on my order after it shipped to see the word(simulated)

I dont feel that they are clearly advertising that theyre selling cubic zirconias as real. Also that on sale I was charged 1100 dollars for a fake.

When i reached out I was told that I could pay extra for an upgrade. When I thought about it, I realized how underhanded this company is.

I dont feel that I should have to pay shipping either! Im taking this to consumer protection.

Preferred solution:

Full refund

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Apr 01, 2025 to: Christin J Bzr's review

Thank you for choosing Agape Diamonds and reaching out to us!
Please note that all of our jewelry is made to order, and it typically takes 5-7 business days to manufacture before it is shipped. The shipping method you selected at checkout will determine the transit time once your order leaves our facility.
We understand that you initially requested a cancellation, followed by an email to proceed with shipping, and then another cancellation request the following day. This has caused some confusion for both our customer service team and the manufacturing team. Rest assured, your request is being processed.
We appreciate your patience and understanding!
Christin J Bzr

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Checking an order I placed on the 22.nd with 2 day delivery

Nothing happened. I was on hold 2 different times for almost an hour combined between the 2 calls. I am now requesting a refund.

Preferred solution:

Full refund

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Nov 26, 2024 to: Philip T Ohb's review

Thank you for shopping with Agape Diamonds. We received your email and have responded, . Please use customerservoce@agapediamonds.com for customer service needs.
Philip T Ohb

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Locating order

I ordered earings on 11/11. Fed ex tells me they are sending it back to you because the package had no contents.

Can you please help me out on this. What to do?

Loss:
$600
Preferred solution:

Deliver product or service ordered

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Mar 21, 2024 to: Guest-5711644's review

Hello,
Please email us at customerservoce@agapediamonds.com or call us at 1-800-861-5144
Thank you
Anonymous

This review is written by an individual who has purchased the reviewed product/service and/or confirms being a paying customer of this company. Check our FAQ

Verified Buyer
| map-marker Phoenix, Arizona

Return or exchange

Contains 1 confidential file for company representatives

Order # 10021****

Good Morning, I spoke with one of your representatives and was advised to contact customer service in order to return or exchange the order that I made on 3/11/24. My wife thinks that the earrings are too big and would like to exchange it to something smaller; wed truly appreciate it.

Thank you

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jan 19, 2023 to: Eric E Gvx's review

Thank you for reaching out. Please contact us at 1-800-861-5144
Eric E Gvx

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Clarity

Clarity and customer service. No one will answer the phone nor return emails since I asked questions about the clarity of the ear rings

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Sep 20, 2022 to: MaryAlice C Kdb's review

Hello,
Please email customerservice@agapediamonds.com for assistance.
MaryAlice C Kdb

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

I would like to see some ring guards

I have three ring I like I was wondering if you had a ring guard that works with them?

My new ring set that I am getting is for my 50th Wedding Anniversary,

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jun 23, 2022 to: Guest-3697599's review

Thank you for being an Agape Diamonds customer! You should contact Agape Diamonds Customer Service department directly, this is a forum and not a proper way to contact Agape Diamonds when you need your order resized or serviced. You need to email customerservice@agapediamonds.com
Anonymous
map-marker Hammonton, New Jersey

My engagement ring and 2 wedding bands need to be resized from size 6 to 5.5. Also a diamond is missing on one of the bands

I need this ring back by 8/1/22. I called about it a month ago and never received anything to send it back

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jan 21, 2022 to: Restilyn P's review

Thank you for shopping with Agape Diamonds! We are happy to hear that you think our Jewelry is beautiful. Please email our customer support for assistance with an exchange @ customerservice@agapediamonds.com
Restilyn P

Return or exchange

I want the item so beautiful, but its so big in my ear so I want the small only the 2 carat earring & pendant.

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Dec 13, 2021 to: Mike H Qki's review

Thank you for shopping with Agape Diamonds!
Happy you were able to get in touch with us:)
Resolved
Mike H Qki

Resolved: Inability to contact anyone at their toll-free number and desire to return /exchange a purchase

Updated by user Dec 08, 2021

Refund and exchange for similar product at similar price.

Original review Dec 08, 2021

The complaint did get forwarded to Agape and they have been back in regular communication online only . Perhaps they are cutting back on hiring costs as the result of a financial re-structuring , but they have been in good communication via Email and are acting willing to work with me on the return / exchange .

Pros:
  • Low relative cost
Preferred solution:

Refund / exchange

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Nov 02, 2021 to: Pamela D Qpn's review

Thank you for shopping with Agape Diamonds. Please email our customer service department for assistance at customerservice@agapediamonds.com
Our customer service department will respond within 1 business day
Pamela D Qpn

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Diamond Came out

I purchase the Princess Cut Channel Set Catherdral Style Engagement Ring in July. My diamond came out over the weekend.

I did find it. I need to know what to do?

My Order number is 10016****. My telephone number is 601-248-****

Sincerely,

Pamela David

Preferred solution:

My ring to be fixed in a timely manner

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Nov 02, 2021 to: Tiffany A Qcs's review

Thank you for shopping with Agape Diamonds. Please email our customer service department for assistance at customerservice@agapediamonds.com
Our customer service department will respond within 1 business day
Tiffany A Qcs

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Question

Hello my name is Tiffany Adley I purchased a paid of diamond earrings order number 10015**** (*.0CTW Round Cut Stud Earrings in 14K White Gold (2.0Ct Each).

I am aware that these are man made diamonds but under the impression that they could test for diamonds of tested. I had them clean and tested and came back as glass. Can you explain to me why they didnt test as Diamonds?

Preferred solution:

Full refund

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jul 23, 2021 to: Denise J Bix's review

Please email customerservice@agapediamonds.com for assistance regarding your order
Denise J Bix

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Refund

Hello, my name's Denise Jean-Louis.

For some unknown reasons, my order was returned to you and had never gotten to my door. No need to send it back, whick means, i cancel tbe order.

I demand that you return the money to Affirm, so I can get a refund of the payment that i already made I'm waiting on your decision, so is Affirm. Thanks.

Loss:
$2
Preferred solution:

Full refund

Agape Diamonds's reply dated Jun 03, 2021 to: Marjorie C Pfx's review

Thank you for your review. After looking up your order we see that you returned the jewelry for a store credit and recently requested to use the store credit towards Model: RSE-SALE-1.0CT-14KW
We sent a email requesting you to verify your shipping address since your original order is 6 months old.
Please email customerservice@agapediamonds.com so we can assist you further
Marjorie C Pfx

I never was credited for return item and being billed monthly

I was told I have a credit for 588.00 dollars but never sent the credit information to order something else where is my money or credit

Loss:
$588
Preferred solution:

Full refund

Contact Information

Website:
Mailing Address:
14341 N Dale Mabry Hwy
Tampa, Florida 33618
United States
Phone:
(800) 861-5144
Contact Agape Diamonds Customer Service

Latest Question

Im approved for 850$ my purchase was a total of 700$ why doesnt the rest of my loan cover the processing fee. I have 150$ after my 700$ purchase. Your 79$ processing fee just cost you all 700$

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article